Ice Cream Cakes

Please call us at 228-3225 to order a custom​ ice cream cake.

48 to 24 hours notice for custom cakes is appreciated.

Pre-Made Ice Cream Cakes

We keep a large selection of pre-decorated ice cream cakes in our dining room cake freezer. We'll happily write a personal message on any cake free of charge! Each pre-made Arnie's ice cream cake is made the same way... vanilla soft serve outside, chocolate and vanilla soft serve layers inside with cold fudge and cake crunch in the middle.

Custom Ice Cream Cakes

Create your own custom cake in any of the sizes listed below. Custom cakes can be made with any of our hard ice cream and/or soft serve ice cream flavors. We can also decorate your custom cake to your specifications - please note that an art charge of $5 or more will be applied if the requested decorations are outside of our normal styles.

Sizes & Pricing

Size
6" Round
8" Round
10" Round
9" Heart
10" x 14" Rectangle

Servings
4 to 6
8 to 10
12 to 16
8 to 10
16 to 20

Price
$14.95
$23.95
$29.95
$23.95
$39.95

Hard Ice Cream
$16.95
$26.95
$33.95
$26.95
Not available 

---

Ice Cream Cake Gallery